The initial motion was to deny awarding the "Certificate of Appropriateness" which, to clarify, is required in order to secure a building permit. The motion was seconded and after more discussion voted on. Fortunately there were 3 nays to the 5 count vote. After more debate, a second motion was made to award appropriateness to the design with some alteration which would be reviewed for approval by staff at a later date. The motion was seconded and voted on with 3 in favor and 2 against.